I'll just throw my two cents in for a great starter. I may replace Pedro Martinez with Whitey Ford. I also wouldn't include any active players, Arod and so forth. I am not a big Red Sox or Yankees fan so I am neutral in my opinions. Bill Dickey would also have my vote over Johnny Bench. I have been wishing someone would replace the All-time players in 2k12 with alternate choices but I have no clue about modding and don't even know if it is possible or not.