I did my own research and I've got an entire list that should include every fake/real player. I've also listed team in the game followed by organization actually in as of the time I checked. Some could have changed in the last week or two. The hitters list was mostly someone else's work, although I filled in a few things they were missing. The list of pitchers is almost entirely my own research. It seems there were two fake Ryan Feierabends in the game. Basically identical profiles. Also there's a fake Alfredo Amezaga and he's already in the game. All of the players are guys with previous major league experience. The only prospect is Trevor Reckling of the Angels. I checked a few teams and didn't find any, so I don't think there are many others, if any, and I'm not sure why Reckling was included. I'm sure I've made a mistake or two, but I've double-checked mostly everything. It's probably too late for most anyone to care anymore, but here it is anyway:
BATTERS
Manny Veras Freddy Guzman BAL
Clyde White Michael Barrett BAL
Ross Ford Jarrett Hoffpauir BAL WAS
Felix Lee Argenis Reyes BAL CLE
Omar Blanco Brad Eldred BAL DET
Denny Crawford Gabe Kapler BOS
Rob Nelson Carlos Maldonado BOS WAS
Wayne Gallagher Tug Hulett BOS PHI
Jake Martinez Brent Dlugach BOS DET
Buck Henderson Brian Anderson NYY COL
Mack Stanley Tommy Everidge NYY
Jerry Miller Justin Maxwell NYY HOU
Jose Cox Robb Quinlan NYY
Doug Goodwin Chad Tracy NYY COL
Mark Reed Josh Whitesell TB
Howard Wagner Josh Donaldson TB OAK
Mark Cooper Brian Bocock TB TOR
Nate Jacobs Michael Aubrey TB WAS
Ramon Silva Craig Stansberry TOR SDP
Mark Butler Mike Hessman TOR
Rick Ramirez Randy Ruiz TOR
Martin Gonzalez Raul Chavez TOR NYM
Joel Stewart Fernando Perez CHA
Jim Ford Ryan Church CHA
Tom Edwards Bobby Scales CHA NYM
Craig Davis Chris Richard CHA
Lew Coleman Dusty Ryan CHA NYM
Shawn Gibson Frank Catalanotto CHA
Andy Torres Angel Salome CHA SEA
Humberto Cabrera Jamie Burke CLE
Dave Perry Troy Glaus CLE
Lou Smith Jerry Owens CLE
Reggie Sanchez T.J. Bohn CLE
Jose Ross Chris Duncan DET
Hal Baldwin Brian Buscher DET
Jesus Rivera Alex Cintron DET
Chris Wheeler Mitch Jones DET
Dick Jackson Brian Barden DET
Zach Parker Rob Bowen DET
Franklin Rivera Bengie Molina KC
Marco Moreno Jose Guillen KC
Bill Holt Delwyn Young KC CWS
Chris Hall Ryan Garko KC
Damon Morse Niuman Romero KC DET
Juan Ramirez Ramon Vazquez MIN
Frank Martinez Tony Pena Jr. MIN BOS
Chris Lyons Willy Aybar LAA
Jim Jordan Kevin Richardson LAA
Henry Sanchez Freddy Sandoval LAA
Don Thomas Hank Blalock LAA
Vicente Rodriguez Alfredo Amezaga (already in game!) OAK
Charley Adams Matt Mangini OAK TAM
Pete Kennedy Anderson Hernandez OAK PIT
Duane Myers Jeff Bailey OAK MIN
Claude Chapman David Eckstein OAK
Karl Roberts Richie Sexson OAK
Jonathan McGovert Micah Hoffpauir OAK
Andy Inglett Akinori Iwamura SEA
Oscar Blanco Gregorio Petit SEA CLE
Johnny Eaton Scott Podsednik TEX BOS
Charlie Lind Mike Lowell TEX
Larry Fisher Kevin Russo TEX NYY
Chuck Anderson Steve Tolleson TEX BAL
Pedro Arias Michel Hernandez TEX
Jeff Wright Adam Stern TEX
Dave Dunn Andy Marte TEX PIT
Garry Howell Brad Nelson TEX TEX
Cesar Vargas Carlos Delgado ATL
Ramon Fuentes Barbaro Canizares ATL
Benny Wells Randy Winn ATL
Al Cash Chad Moeller ATL
Rob Baldwin Kazuo Matsui ATL
Casey McCormick Luis Castillo ATL
Archie Schmidt Travis Ishikawa MIA MIL
Kelly Hairston Eric Bruntlett MIA
Buddy Lindstrom Oscar Salazar MIA
Steve Morales Reid Gorecki MIA
Brad Snell Brad Davis MIA SDP
Lloyd Leach Matt Tuiasosopo MIA NYM
Felix Rosario Jeff Frazier MIA DET
Chris Ford Ryan Budde MIA ARI
Edwin Gonzalez Ruben Gotay MIA TOR
Brent Turner Chris Shelton NYM NYM
Tony Rivera Andy Gonzalez NYM MIL
Kelly Martin Matt Kata NYM TEX
Martin Gil Josh Barfield PHI BAL
Roger Burns Rusty Ryal PHI ARI
Richie Marshall Mike Jacobs PHI ARI
Jack Gutierrez Luke Carlin PHI CLE
Tomas Romero Alex Romero WAS
Brian Burton Wladimir Balentien WAS
Fred Wilhelm Brendan Harris WAS COL
Dick Evans Lucas May WAS NYM
Dick Johnson Clint Sammons WAS
John May Jeff Salazar CHC TAM
Darrell Robinson Luis Esposito CHC BAL
Allan Powell Joe Dillon CIN TAM
Ryan Sullivan Jody Gerut CIN
Mark Bell Gary Matthews Jr. CIN
Ray Bell Guillermo Quiroz CIN SEA
Paul Young Mike Redmond CIN
Al Crawford Cory Aldridge CIN LAA
Lefty Baker Rhyne Hughes CIN
Jon Anderson Ronnie Belliard HOU
Jimmy Murphy Drew Macias HOU
Allen Wallace Joe Koshansky HOU SFG
Charlie Kennedy Kila Ka'aihue HOU OAK
Mark James Brandon Jones MIL
Luis Alomar Edwin Maysonet MIL MIL
Wilson Cedeno Wilkin Castillo MIL COL
George Munson Argenis Diaz MIL DET
Manny Diaz Angel Berroa MIL
Mike Hansen Nick Stavinoha MIL
Ray Greene Josh Fields PIT LAD
Kurt Wolfe Cristian Guzman PIT
Jorge Austin Nick Johnson STL BAL
Sammy Harris Steven Hill STL
Bernie Gibson Corky Miller STL
Ray Henderson Josh Anderson ARI
Trevor Smith Andy Tracy ARI
Charles Patterson Gabe Gross ARI
Pete Hoffman Daniel Nava ARI BOS
Don Peterson Tony Abreu ARI KRC
Luke Ross Tommy Manzella ARI MIL
Billy George Brent Clevlen ARI ARI
Alex Infante Hernan Iribarren COL
Don Sandberg Mike Sweeney COL
Kelvin Morris Jordan Brown LAD MIL
Orlando Matos Pedro Feliz LAD SDP
Mike Chavez Jim Edmonds LAD
Ray Sullivan Reggie Abercrombie LAD
George Baez Jay Payton LAD
George Cruz Ryan Shealy SD
Tony Marshall Mike Rabelo SD
Rudy Ramirez Robinzon Diaz SD LAA
Don Stone Gregor Blanco SF SF
Jesus Perez Joaquin Arias SF SFG
Jeremy Cooper Nick Green SF MIA
Rodney Allen Jeff Larish SF PIT
Rod Smith Fernando Tatis SF
Scott Lee Kevin Cash FA
Felipe Marquez Edwin Bellorin FA
Jeff Harris John Hester FA LAA
Justin Richardson Brian Esposito FA CIN
Jason Wagner Paul Phillips FA TOR
Robert Jackson Max Ramirez FA KCR
Rafael Liriano Paul Hoover FA
Willie Castillo Konrad Schmidt FA ARI
Randy Jefferson Max St. Pierre FA
Rex Shields Gregg Zaun FA
Reggie Young Bryan Anderson FA STL
Paul Gardner Jeff Clement FA PIT
Johnny Gregg Aaron Bates FA
Jerry Thomas Garrett Atkins FA
Danny Hill Paul McAnulty FA LAA
Shane Barnes Chad Huffman FA CLE
Aaron Phillips Mike Lamb FA
Shawn King John Lindsey FA
Luis Pena Danny Richar FA
Alan Wright Scott Moore FA HOU
Rocky Coleman Luis Hernandez FA TEX
Ben Lee Lance Zawadzki FA ATL
Buster Watkins Augie Ojeda FA
Rafael Pena Mark Grudzielanek FA
Sam Wagner Hector Luna FA PHI
Zack Hughes Kevin Frandsen FA PHI
Jim Hudson Bobby Crosby FA
Arnie Baldwin Luis Cruz FA LAD
Johnny Powell Oswaldo Navarro FA NYM
Carlos Castro Chris W. Carter FA
Dee Baker Manny Ramirez FA OAK
Kazuo Choo Kevin Mench FA
Grant Bennett Mike Ryan FA PIT
Jason Yount Cory Sullivan FA
Miguel Gonzalez Matt Watson FA
Ray Escobar Garret Anderson FA
Alex Ledezma Adam Loewen FA NYM
Ramon Perez Terry Evans FA KCR
Floyd Kelly Willy Taveras FA
Dave Perez Jesus Feliciano FA TAM
Will Harrell John Raynor FA PIT
Mel Olivo Matt Carson FA MIN
Rex Leach Jonathan Van Every FA
Tony Aybar Rocco Baldelli FA
PITCHERS
Doug McCarty Jenrry Mejia FA NYM
Flelix Ramirez Luke French FA MIN
Darrell Jones Nate Robertson FA CHC
Brett Hill Kenshin Kawakami FA FA
Hank Porter Hayden Penn FA FA
Carlos Cordero Oliver Perez FA SEA
Denny Smith John Maine FA NYY
Yamaico Bell Yorman Bazardo FA FA
Ray Murphy Virgil Vasquez FA FA
Charley Valentine Josh Towers FA Retired
Howie Phillips Kirk Saarloos FA Retired
Gregg Burns Robert Ray FA MIA
Erick Martinez Chris Sampson FA FA
Billy Baker Zach Jackson FA TEX
Luis Alvarez Romulo Sanchez FA TB
Jim Wolfe Jake Woods FA FA
Mel Ramirez Rafael Rodriguez FA ARI
Corey Andrews Brian Slocum FA FA
Freddie Williams Kevin Mulvey FA FA
Preston Mendoza Sean West FA MIA
Nelson Wagner Anthony Lerew FA FA
Herb Davis Boof Bonser FA SF
Ed Sanders Aaron Poreda FA PIT
Greg Green Robert Coello FA TOR
Charlie Slaughter Todd Wellemeyer FA Retired
Luke Sweeney Billy Buckner FA BOS
Pete Simpson Jason Bergmann FA OAK
Mel Howell Jason Waddell FA Retired
Randy Watkins Cesar Carrillo FA FA
Julio Pena Jailen Peguero FA HOU
Enrique Nunez Charlie Haeger FA BOS
Jim Corcoran Jason Hirsh FA FA
Roy Allen Daniel Davidson FA LAA
Carlos Nunez Manuel Corpas FA CHC
Max Patterson Pedro Feliciano FA NYY
William Adams Henry Villar FA HOU
Toby Johnson Gil Meche FA FA
Brian Freeman Joe Nelson FA FA
Brett Sinkbeil Glenn Graham FA PIT
Jackie Wright Carlos Rosa FA FA
William Wallace Dan Meyer FA FA
Kelly Wolfe Randy Flores FA FA
Cesar Infante Juan Rincon FA LAA
Seth Bell Neal Musser FA NYM
Harvey Schmidt Steven Shell FA FA
Frank Hunter Edwar Ramirez FA FA
Charlie Leon Saul Rivera FA FA
Dennis Kennedy Bob Howry FA FA
Les Morris Royce Ring FA COL
Jeff Bennett Alfredo Figaro FA FA
Tom Watson Frank Mata FA FA
Clyde Nelson Joe Bisenius FA FA
Manny Cruz Steven Jackson FA PIT
George Sheets Casey Fien FA MIN
Wilfredo Garcia Doug Mathias FA BOS
A.J. Burke Alex Hinshaw FA SD
Jake Lowe Chad Cordero FA FA
Chad Stone Dustin Richardson FA FA
Gustavo Romero Samuel Gervacio FA FA
Elmer Carlson Evan MacLane FA FA
Charlie Howard Gregory Infante FA CHW
Leon Owen James Houser FA FA
Luis Blanco Jhan Marinez FA CHW
Ruben Martinez Luis Pedromo FA MIN
Clyde Smith Chris Seddon FA CLE
Darrell Jordan Mike Lincoln FA FA
Leo Myers Jesus Colome FA COL
Amos Martin Casey Daigle FA SF
Eric Craig Fu-Te Ni FA DET
Billy Thompson Leo Rosales FA NYM
Floyd Moore Taylor Tankersley FA FA
German Guzman Scott Schoenweis FA FA
Chad Watson Jon Meloan FA FA
Brandon Smith Brian Schlitter FA CHC
Andres Olivo Anthony Ortega FA FA
M. Schmidt Ben Sheets DET FA
W. Wood Esmilin Caridad DET CHC
? *60 Josh Fogg DET FA
B. Rogers Gary Majewski DET FA
Chris Contreras Clay Condrey DET FA
Julio Martinez Fabio Castro DET OAK
G. Wright David Patton DET FA
W. Reynolds Daniel Stange MIN SD
D. Schultz Brian Bannister CHW FA
L. Harris Matt Fox CHW SEA
K. Allen Jeff Suppan CHW SDP
B. Abreu John Parrish CHW FA
T. Carroll Scot Shields CHW FA
B. Moreno Oscar Villareal CHW BAL
J. Cabrera Eric Hurley CHW LAA
D. Haynes T.J. Beam CHW FA
J. Hatfield Chris Bootcheck CHW DET
L. Ramos Vladimir Nunez CHW FA
E. Patterson Jeff Ridgway CHW WAS
J. Nelson Jhonny Nunez CHW TB
M. Olivares Chris Waters NYY FA
D. Navarro Denny Bautista NYY FA
W. Hughes Dustin Nippert NYY FA
? *63 Ian Snell NYY FA
T. Baker Brian Bass NYY HOU
J. Young Jay Sborz NYY ATL
J. Almonte Warner Madrigal NYY NYY
N. Roberts Rich Rundles NYY FA
G. Sweeney Chris Lambert NYY FA
S. Martinez Greg Aquino NYY CHW
D. Griffin Trevor Reckling LAA LAA
G. Bell Claudio Vargas LAA FA
C. Miller Jeff Bennett LAA FA
S. Harris joe Martinez LAA ARI
J. Sullivan Fernando Hernandez LAA TOR
E. Gallagher Graham Taylor LAA MIA
C. Campbell Billy Petrick HOU FA
R. Baez Carlos Martinez HOU FA
V. Carter Jorge Sosa OAK FA
D. Farris Danny Farquhar TOR TOR
C. Booker Chad Becker TOR TOR
H. Ford Mike Hinckley TOR FA
P. Cox Scott Strickland TOR FA
V. Gonzalez Garrett Olson ATL NYM
R. Adams Jamie Moyer ATL COL
J. Simon Matt Chico ATL FA
F. Murray Justin Duchscherer ATL FA
W. Turner Tim Redding FA TOR
T. Powell Luis Atilano MIL CIN
D. Davis Chad Ho Park MIL MIL
R. Maloney Brian Sweeney MIL SEA
R. Rios Kiko Calero MIL FA
H. Baldwin Adalberto Mendez MIL FA
R. Zimmerman James Parrish MIL ATL
E. Cook Zack Segovia MIL COL
R. Hunter Kris Benson MIL FA
H. Fisher Jared Wells MIL COL
R. Harris Carlos Guevera MIL FA
J. Torres Jorge Campillo STL FA
H. Booker Gustavo Chacin STL FA
J. Nelson Adam Ottavino STL COL
S. LaRoche Chris Smith STL FA
C. Marquez Fernando Cabrera STL NYM
J. Taylor Ross Wolf STL TEX
S. Miller Jack Taschner STL FA
B. Murphy Carlos Torres STL COL
M. Moore Ryan Feierabend STL FA
C. Sweeney John Koronka STL FA
E. Lopez Yoslan Herrera STL FA
D. Weber Andy Pettitte CHC NYY
E. Snyder Carlos Silva CHC FA
J. Ross Jensen Lewis CHC ARI
F. Cruz Justin Miller CHC FA
H. Ward Justin Lehr CHC FA
L. Dillon Sean Henn CHC SEA
L. Reynolds Neal Cotts CHC TEX
D. Harris Dirk Hayhurst ARI FA
C. Campbell Greg Smith ARI LAA
R. Jackson Clay Zavada ARI STL
G. Moore Bobby Seay ARI FA
C. Corcoran Damaso Marte ARI FA
L. Guzman Justin Thomas ARI NYY
C. Jordan Greg Burke ARI BAL
C. Murray Sean Gallagher LAD CIN
S. Carter Jeff Weaver LAD FA
B. Sax Mike Hampton LAD FA
T. Baez Winston Abreu LAD FA
F. Chapman Robinson Tejada SF FA
B. Wright Elmer Dessens SF FA
J. Colon Garrett Mock SF BOS
D. Baker Brian Moehler SF FA
M. Pena Armando Gabino SF FA
B. May Jesse English SF FA
H. Bailey Craig Hansen SF FA
F. Alvarez Arturo Lopez SF NYM
D. Hill Shane Loux SF SF
C. Kennedy Corey Kluber CLE CLE
N. Kennedy Jeremy Sowers CLE FA
B. Fox Renyel Pinto CLE FA
G. Long Royce Corcoran CLE FA
B. Gibson Brad Thompson CLE MIN
H. Perez Kelvin Jimenez CLE FA
L. Chavez Yasmeiro Petit SEA SFG
H. Castillo Ryan Rowland-Smith SEA CHC
A. Colon Ramon A. Ramirez SEA FA
J. Parra Fredy Dolsi SEA FA
B. Hughes Vinnie Chulk SEA MIL
J. Torres Walter Silva SEA FA
R. Olivo Hector Ambriz MIA CLE
E. Hernandez Travis Schlichting MIA OAK
O. Salazar Tobi Stoner MIA FA
F. Pena Jose Capellan MIA FA
J. Pena Scott Olsen NYM CHW
J. Allen Jonathan Albaladejo NYM ARI
H. Corcoran Cedrick Bowers NYM FA
E. Wagner Fernando Nieve NYM LAD
C. Crawford David Riske NYM FA
G. Delgado Daniel Cabrera NYM PIT
P. Bell Wes Whisler NYM CHW
B. Green Donnie Veal WAS CHW
B. Britton Ronald Belisario BAL LAD
D. Carter Carlos Monasterios BAL FA
E. Thomas Joselo Diaz BAL FA
S. Robertson Dennis Sarfate BAL FA
P. Graham Victor Marte BLA SLT
K. Murphy Manny Delcarmen SD NYY
D. Leonard Geoff Geary SD FA
W. Jacobs Cesar Valdez SD FA
D. Cedeno Aquillino Lopez SD FA
C. Henry Thomas Diamond PHI FA
R. Lindstrom Zach Miner PHI DET
M. Everidge Shairon Martis PHI PIT
L. Clarke Ryan Feierabend (again) PHI FA
W. Clarke Bryan Bullington PIT FA
R. DiMaggio Cla Meredith PIT FA
L. Thompson Jon Link PIT SDP
B. Berger Bobby Mosebach PIT SDP
P. Morales Victor Garate PIT MIL
D. Herrera Erick Threets PIT OAK
R. Carter Angel Guzman TEX LAD
J. Perry Brad Kilby TEX OAK
M. Manuel Robert Manuel TEX FA
D. Berry Omar Poveda TEX MIA
J. Pearson Jack Egbert TEX NYM
J. Griffin Shawn Hill TB FA
C. Freeman J.D. Martinez TB MIA
M. Walker Sean White TB LAA
J. Moore Kurt Birkins TB COL
K. Morris Brent Leach TB FA
C. May Lance Broadway TB TOR
R. Chapman Anthony Claggett TB FA
J. Flaherty Eric DuBose BOS FA
J. Bauer Justin James BOS FA
A. Stone Josh Banks CIN BAL
R. Patton Josh Geer CIN SDP
G. Miller Steve Register CIN TOR
E. Pena Kelvim Escobar COL FA
A. Mendez Jeremy Bonderman COL FA
R. Carroll Russ Springer COl FA
D. Depaula Roman Colon COL KC
F. Barker Darrell Rasner COL FA
D. Pearce Chad Paronto COL FA
W. Phillips Eddie Bonine KC PHI
K. Harris Kelvin Herrera KC KC
S. Bailey Mark Rogers KC MIL
A. Schmidt Anthony Reyes KC SDP
J. Moore Trevor Hoffman KC FA
C. Redmond Bob Keppel KC FA
J. Blanco Brian Stokes KC ARI
